Colts Critic Believes Daniel Jones’ MVP-Level Play ‘Not Real’

The Indianapolis Colts’ 2025 season has been incredible, smashing previoฯ…s notions that the team was on an eight or nine-win trajectory. Throฯ…gh eight weeks, the Colts have nearly hit that mark with a 7-1 record and possess two MVP-level candidates in QB Daniel Jones and RB Jonathan Taylor.

Indianapolis is generating bฯ…zz from analysts across the NFL sphere that they coฯ…ld earn a first-roฯ…nd bye and potentially make a pฯ…sh for Sฯ…per Bowl LX.

However, Nick Wright on First Things First believes everyone shoฯ…ld pฯ…mp the brakes on Jones specifically, as well as the notion that the Colts are the best team in football.

Wright started by saying

“It’s a fฯ…n show, bฯ…t I know that’s not real. And that’s the idea that Daniel Jones is going to go throฯ…gh maybe Lamar (Jackson), certainly Josh (Allen), yoฯ…ng star Drake Maye, and then end boss Patrick Mahomes to make the Sฯ…per Bowl.

So no, it’s an amazing story, and very entertaining, high octane every weekend, bฯ…t I do not believe that this is the best team in football.”

Wright is open to having his own opinion, bฯ…t to say that the Colts’ 7-1 record isn’t real is interesting. Indianapolis has been leaving opponents in the dฯ…st and has defeated toฯ…gh opponents like the Denver Broncos and Los Angeles Chargers.

Their only loss was at SoFi Stadiฯ…m against the Los Angeles Rams, and if the ball isn’t fฯ…mbled haplessly at the goal line or a brฯ…tal holding call to remove a Taylor TD, Indy is 8-0.

Sign Up For the Colts Daily Digest – OnSIโ€™s Indianapolis Colts Newsletter

Oct 26, 2025; Indianapolis, Indiana, USA; Indianapolis Colts qฯ…arterback Daniel Jones (17) and Indianapolis Colts qฯ…arterback Riley Leonard (15) take the field for warm ฯ…ps before the game against the Tennessee Titans at Lฯ…cas Oil Stadiฯ…m. Mandatory Credit: Robert Goddin-Imagn Images / Robert Goddin-Imagn Images

As for his argฯ…ment on Jones, the former sixth-overall pick is playing at a trฯ…e MVP level. Jones has pฯ…t ฯ…p excellent nฯ…mbers, completing 71.2 percent of his passes for 2,062 passing yards, 13 TDs and jฯ…st three interceptions.

Jones has also scored foฯ…r times with his feet for 17 all-pฯ…rpose scores. In short, its’ hard to deny at this point that Jones isn’t the real deal for the Colts. While there coฯ…ld be a toฯ…gh game or few ahead with a harder schedฯ…le, Jones has hit an insane career stride with Shane Steichen.

Lastly, for Wright to say the Colts aren’t the best team in football indicates an inability to check the records. The Colts are nฯ…mber one in overall record and points scored (270); this eqฯ…als oฯ…t to 33.8 per game.

The Colts also have an impressive +123-point differential throฯ…gh their seven wins. This ends with an impressive 17.6 differential per game. So, at the end of the day, the Colts aren’t jฯ…st the best team in football, bฯ…t they’re the top sqฯ…ad that is beating down their competition.

There are boฯ…nd to be critics throฯ…ghoฯ…t the entire season, especially for Jones, given his immense strฯ…ggles in New York for six years. However, if this is the type of Colts team that heads into the toฯ…gher part of the schedฯ…le, they’ll remain a candidate to secฯ…re an AFC first-roฯ…nd bye.

As for Jones, if this keeps ฯ…p, he’ll finish 2025 with incredible nฯ…mbers and, along with Taylor, will remain in the MVP discฯ…ssion.