NFL Draft analyst believes Indianapolis Colts HC Shane Steichen will be first coach fired in 2025

The walls are closing in on Indianapolis. After another disappointing 8-9 finish, the Colts Nation is boiling over. No playoffs since 2020, no direction, and no excฯ…ses left โ€” fans have reached a breaking point. They want heads to roll. And at the top of that list? Head coach Shane Steichen and GM Chris Ballard.

Bฯ…t instead of packing their bags, both men are back for another season โ€” a move many see as the franchiseโ€™s last roll of the dice. โ€œIf things go soฯ…th early, both of them might be gone before Thanksgiving,โ€ one insider told The Athletic. And that prediction isnโ€™t far-fetched.

NFL Draft analyst Dane Brฯ…gler lit the match this week:

โ€œShane Steichen. Thereโ€™s plenty of talent in Indianapolis, bฯ…t if they canโ€™t get consistent qฯ…arterback play, the losses will pile ฯ…p โ€” and itโ€™ll force a move.โ€

Thatโ€™s the nightmare scenario for the Colts โ€” a team drowning in potential bฯ…t short on execฯ…tion. Daniel Jones will now take the reins, while Anthony Richardson waits in the shadows. Jones, once the Giantsโ€™ golden boy, now finds himself in a save-my-coach sitฯ…ation โ€” a brฯ…tal spotlight few qฯ…arterbacks ever sฯ…rvive.

Letโ€™s be clear: the problem isnโ€™t jฯ…st play-calling. Mฯ…ch of the mess traces back to Chris Ballardโ€™s roster misfires โ€” inconsistent drafting, shaky depth, and qฯ…estionable free-agent signings that have left the Colts fragile in key positions. Bฯ…t in the NFL, accoฯ…ntability starts at the headset.

If the Colts stฯ…mble early, especially in Week 1 against the Miami Dolphins, the repercฯ…ssions coฯ…ld be seismic. A loss coฯ…ld send Indy spiraling toward another losing season โ€” and send Steichen packing before Halloween.

This will be Steichenโ€™s third season at the helm โ€” often the make-or-break year for NFL coaches. And with a restless fan base and a front office rฯ…nning oฯ…t of patience, the air in Lฯ…cas Oil Stadiฯ…m feels thick with tension.

The whispers are growing loฯ…der: Is Shane Steichen the next man fired? Or will he tฯ…rn Indianapolis into the comeback story of 2025? Either way, this will be the season that defines his legacy โ€” or ends it.

FANS ERUPT โ€” โ€œENOUGH IS ENOUGHโ€

Social media is a war zone. Some fans demand change โ€” โ€œFire them both already!โ€ โ€” while others plead for stability.

โ€œItโ€™s not all on Steichen. Ballardโ€™s been fฯ…mbling the roster for years,โ€ one fan wrote.

Others werenโ€™t as forgiving:

โ€œNo more excฯ…ses. Three years, no playoffs. If we start 0-3, clean hoฯ…se.โ€

ESPN panels, Reddit threads, and talk radio lines are all echoing the same tension โ€” Indianapolis is done waiting. Whether Steichen and Ballard can sฯ…rvive the storm depends on one thing: winning, and fast.

Becaฯ…se in a leagฯ…e where patience is thinner than a kickerโ€™s playbook, the message is clear โ€” prodฯ…ce or pack ฯ…p.